Woman standing in front of a mirror with a red question mark as the reflection

Maybe we’re just not cut out for this

Reading Time: 4 minutes

By Sia Papageorgiou, Centre for Strategic Communication Excellence: 

I’ve spent the last 10 years teaching communication professionals to step up and own their strategic space. To stop waiting for permission from the C-suite and start influencing and shaping culture, managing risk and building trust. 

But maybe I was wrong. 

Maybe we’re not cut out for this. 

Because let’s be honest, how many more reports do we need to tell us that just 17% of executives feel their communication and public affairs functions are well equipped to navigate the current environment? 

The reality is: 

  • We’re still seen as tacticians, not trusted advisors. 
  • Business leaders want insight and influence, but we keep handing them email open and click rates. 
  • In interviews with CEOs, CFOs and other executives, many admit their communication teams don’t fully understand the business model or value drivers and often arrive too late to shape outcomes. 
  • And despite rising organisational risks from societal division to AI disruption, few leaders believe we have the skills or mindsets to help them navigate complexity, let alone lead through it. 

If our profession hasn’t figured this out by now, maybe we never will. 

Maybe we are the people who draft talking points after the real decisions are made. Maybe getting a seat at the decision-making table is a fairytale. Maybe we should stop trying to lead and just settle for being the best corporate wordsmiths we can be. 

Because that’s easier, isn’t it? No pressure to understand the business. No need to challenge thinking. No awkward moments when you ask, “What’s the business risk here?” and the room goes quiet. 

Stay tactical. Stay comfortable. Let someone else shape the strategy. 

Of course, I don’t actually believe that. 

But the longer we resist building the skills leaders expect, the more likely that cynical narrative becomes reality. 

Most business leaders don’t speak communication. They speak performance, risk, growth, culture and reputation. And they expect us to connect the dots for them. 

Our interviews with executives make it clear: 

  • They want advisors who understand the business, not just the brand. 
  • Trusted partners who surface risks early, especially during crises, mergers or transformation. 
  • Communication leaders who challenge constructively and influence strategy, not just execute tactics. 

Every time I run a strategic communication management training program I see it – brilliant communication professionals struggling to earn influence because they’ve been taught to focus on the wrong things. 

It’s time to stop talking about being more strategic and show it. 

How to change the conversation 

Speak the language of business, not just communication 

Our credibility suffers when we hide behind communication jargon or focus on deliverables no one cares about.  

What to do instead:
Lead every plan, meeting or conversation with the business objective – i.e., what is the business issue and how can your communication make a difference? 

How:
When your leader says, “We need a campaign for this,” push back respectfully but firmly: 

  • “What business problem are we solving?” 
  • “How will success be measured beyond awareness?” 
  • “Is this about behaviour change, building trust, reducing risk?” 

Frame your response around their world: 

  • Instead of: “We’ll run an internal campaign to promote the strategy.” 
  • Say: “Our goal is to increase employee understanding and buy-in, so they deliver on the business strategy. We’ll measure success through alignment, confidence scores and performance data.” 

So, if you don’t know how your organisation makes money, what drives growth or where the risks sit, that’s your starting point. 

Get in early or accept limited influence 

Let’s be honest, most communication professionals still get brought in way too late, when everything’s been decided and all that’s left is execution. 

What to do instead:
Position yourself as a risk mitigator and strategic sounding board. 

How:
Track organisational shifts like restructures, leadership changes, market pressure, and offer insight before being asked (i.e., always come from a place of service): 

  • “I understand a restructure’s on the table. Are we factoring in the cultural risks? I can help flag them early and shape how we talk about them.” 

When you demonstrate your value early, you stop being the person they call on last. 

Stop reporting activity, start demonstrating impact 

Outputs aren’t outcomes. But we continue to drown leaders in dashboards packed with numbers that mean very little. 

What to do instead: 

Stop reporting what you did and start reporting what’s changed (i.e., knowledge, attitudes, behaviours). But to do that, you need to have the right measures in place. 

How:
Instead of: 

  • “We produced three videos and sent 10 newsletters this quarter.”

Say (after you’ve measured said right things): 

  • “Employee understanding of the change increased by 28%. Questions to line managers dropped 40%, signalling greater clarity and confidence.” 

Leaders don’t care about how many channels you used. They want to know if communication influenced trust, confidence or performance. 

Embrace uncertainty as a strategic capability 

The world isn’t getting simpler. We’re surrounded by volatility – AI, societal tensions, stakeholder expectations, disruption – that’s our new normal. 

The most valued communication professionals help leaders navigate that ambiguity. 

What to do instead:
Develop resilience within your team so you can anticipate, adapt and advise. Be on the lookout for emerging issues that could impact your organisation and use those insights to shape your communication approach. 

How: 

  • Facilitate scenario planning with leaders to identify communication risks. 
  • Surface potential reputation gaps or cultural fractures early. 
  • Translate complexity into clear, credible messaging grounded in organisational realities, not corporate spin (and less is more). 

For example, when introducing new technology like AI tools or digital platforms, don’t just execute the communication plan. Create space for real conversations about fears, ethics and trust gaps, then co-create messaging that builds confidence and credibility. 

It’s your call 

Influence isn’t handed to us. You earn it by being relevant, understanding your business, and having the guts to lead beyond your comfort zone. 

I say this because I believe in our profession, and in its power to transform organisations, shape culture and navigate uncertainty. 

But belief isn’t enough. Action is. 

So, we’ve got two options:

Stay comfortable and stay sidelined.

Or get comfortable being uncomfortable by leaning in, speaking up and leading.

No one’s lowering the bar.

And neither should we. 

+++

Sia Papageorgiou is Co-Founder of the Centre for Strategic Communication Excellence and is a Strategic Columnist and a #WeLeadComms honoree.

Onclusive

Written by: Editor

One thought on “Maybe we’re just not cut out for this

  1. Sia,
    I could not agree with you more. I often recommend that organizational communicators take a line operating position for a while so that they understand firsthand the pressures and priorities leaders and managers have. It’s one thing to hear about those things and another entirely to live them. A sidebar career shift for a bit makes it all so much more real and gives the communicator passion and power to take that ever-elusive seat at the executive table. The communicator who has ‘been there’ has earned credibility beyond their skill as a communicator – bonus: communicators generally make great team leaders because they can communicate – it’s a win/win.

    Jacqui d’Eon

Leave a Reply

Follow by Email
LinkedIn
Share