"The cost of poor communication is hiding in plain sight" above wire mesh basket with flaming bank notes

The Cost of Poor Communication: It’s Hiding in Plain Sight

Sia Papageorgiou, FRSA, FCSCE, IABC Fellow, SCMP:

We talk constantly about demonstrating the value of communication. But are we paying enough attention to what ineffective communication is costing our organisations?

I’ve spent years arguing that communication professionals need to demonstrate how our work contributes to business results. I still believe that matters. But there’s another question I think we’re not asking nearly enough.

What is ineffective communication costing our organisations?

I’m not talking about the cost of running a communication function, producing campaigns or investing in technology.

I’m talking about the productivity lost when employees can’t find the information they need. The time spent chasing answers, clarifying instructions or trying to understand decisions. The work that gets duplicated because nobody knows somebody else has already done it.

And the organisational knowledge that disappears because important conversations and decisions are scattered across systems.

These are the consequences of communication that isn’t working. And much of the cost goes unmeasured.

I recently read a research report that really got my attention.

The Hidden Cost of Fragmented Workplace Communication, published by Australian and New Zealand technology company Corro, examines how employees experience digital communication at work and the productivity costs associated with fragmented communication systems.

Led by Dr Alan Davison, Corro’s Head of Research and Capability, the study surveyed 2,553 workers across Australia, New Zealand, Singapore, the United Kingdom and the United States.

The hidden cost of getting work done

The research paints a concerning picture of everyday working life.

Consider these findings:

  • 33% of workers search across communication platforms every day to find a message they know they’ve received.
  • 71% follow up on messages at least weekly to clarify intent or confirm receipt.
  • Around one in five encounter duplicated work every week.
  • Roughly half report that message volume reduces their ability to focus on important work by a moderate amount or more.

None of this is particularly surprising. We’ve all experienced the frustration of searching through emails, Teams conversations and shared folders for something we know exists. We’ve chased responses, repeated explanations and attended meetings to clarify matters we thought had already been resolved.

The remarkable thing isn’t that these experiences exist. It’s how widespread they are, and how readily we’ve accepted them as a normal part of working life.

The researchers also attempted to quantify one element of the productivity cost.

Using a conservative assumption of five minutes per search episode, they estimated that employees lose approximately 13 hours per year searching for messages. For the one in eight workers experiencing both cross-platform and email search difficulties every day, that estimate rises to approximately 40 hours.

An entire working week.

These are modelled estimates, based on employees’ reported search frequency rather than directly measured time. The researchers acknowledge that further work is needed to quantify the full economic cost.

Even allowing for those limitations, the implications are significant.

But searching is only part of the picture. There’s also duplicated work, repeated conversations, unnecessary interruptions and decisions revisited because nobody can find the original reasoning.

Poor communication isn’t just frustrating. It consumes organisational capacity, often without anyone recognising or measuring the cost.

We’ve known poor communication is expensive for years

I remember reading an article by David Grossman in The Holmes Report, now PRovoke Media, back in 2011.

Drawing on research into employee misunderstandings and communication barriers, Grossman highlighted the extraordinary financial consequences of poor workplace communication, including an estimated US$37 billion in costs associated with employee misunderstandings across large organisations surveyed in the US and UK.

It was compelling because it connected communication to something business leaders understand very well – money.

Fifteen years later, organisations have more ways to communicate than ever before. Yet having more technology hasn’t necessarily made communication more effective. In some cases, it’s made information harder to find.

One of Corro’s particularly important findings is that these problems aren’t adequately explained by employees’ age, seniority or individual communication capability.

Instead, the research points to structural issues in how communication environments have developed.

Organisations have accumulated layers of technology, practices and processes over time, often without sufficient consideration of how they work together.

The research found that 81% of workers expected to use four or more communication platforms followed up on messages at least weekly, compared with 61% of those expected to use just one.

Employees adapt, finding ways to navigate the complexity and get their work done. And because the work still gets done, the underlying problems can remain largely invisible.

Are we measuring the wrong things?

We’ve made progress moving beyond activity measures, such as email opens and attendance at town halls, to assessing understanding, behaviour and organisational outcomes.

But even when we measure outcomes, we’re usually evaluating particular communication campaigns, strategies or programs.

Some of the biggest communication problems in organisations have very little to do with the quality of our newsletters, leadership messages or campaigns.

They arise from how information is shared, how decisions are explained, how knowledge is preserved and how people coordinate their work. And because these problems cut across functions, their costs often go unmeasured.\

There’s a difference between measuring the performance of the communication function and measuring how effectively an organisation communicates.

Both matter but they’re not the same thing.

An organisation can have an excellent communication team and still have serious problems with how information flows, decisions are made and work gets done.

Communication is an organisational ecosystem, not just a function

Communication doesn’t begin and end with the communication team.

Every organisation operates within a complex communication ecosystem. It includes the technology people use, the way leaders communicate, how decisions are made and explained, how information is shared and preserved, and the formal and informal practices that develop across teams.

These elements interact, influencing how effectively people understand priorities, coordinate their work, make decisions and achieve organisational objectives.

The communication function has responsibility for particular elements of that system, but it doesn’t own or control all of them.

A communication team can develop an excellent internal communication strategy, but that won’t necessarily resolve problems caused by poorly integrated technology.

It can support leaders to communicate more effectively, but it can’t compensate indefinitely for unclear decision-making processes.

And it can establish channel governance, but that won’t work without leadership commitment and organisational accountability.

The answer isn’t always more communication. Sometimes it’s better governance, clearer processes, more accessible information or changes in how teams work together. As organisations adopt AI, access to reliable information becomes even more important. But these problems need attention with or without AI.

Importantly, not every follow-up conversation or request for clarification represents wasted effort. Dialogue is essential to building shared understanding, particularly when people are working on complex issues.

The challenge is identifying the unnecessary effort generated by communication environments that make everyday work harder than it needs to be.

This requires a whole-of-organisation response.

Communication professionals, business leaders, technology teams, human resources and operational functions all have a part to play.

Communication professionals may not control every part of this system, but we should be helping our organisations understand its impact on performance and working with other functions to improve it.

Making the invisible cost visible

To make those costs visible, we need to assess more than awareness, understanding, behaviour and engagement. We need to examine how information moves through the organisation and how much unnecessary effort employees expend finding and using it.

How much time do people spend searching for information they need to do their jobs?

How often is work repeated because previous decisions or outputs aren’t accessible?

Where are communication problems delaying decisions, creating confusion or affecting service delivery?

And which underlying systems, practices or processes are contributing to those problems?

We’d then work to understand the organisational consequences, rather than stopping at employees’ perceptions of communication.

That might involve combining employee research with workflow analysis, operational data and carefully developed estimates of time and effort lost.

We’d establish a baseline, identify the causes of unnecessary effort and measure whether improvements make a meaningful difference.

Time saved won’t necessarily translate into a cash saving, but it can mean greater capacity, faster decisions, better service or improved quality of work.

Of course, none of this is easy.

It requires collaboration across functions, access to information and a willingness to examine organisational practices that may have developed over many years.

But isn’t that exactly the sort of work strategic communication leaders should be contributing to?

It’s time to broaden the conversation

Corro’s research leaves me with one clear conclusion. Measuring the success of our communication programs isn’t enough. We also need to understand where poor communication is costing organisations time, effort and productive capacity.

When employees lose time searching for information, repeating work or struggling to understand decisions, that’s not just a communication problem. It’s a business problem.

The cost of poor communication is hiding in plain sight.

It’s time we started measuring it.

+++

Sia Papageorgiou is the Co-Founder of the Centre for Strategic Communication Excellence and is a Strategic Columnist

Leave a Reply

Follow by Email
LinkedIn
Share